Discussion doesn’t take place in the comments
| Comments
I know it’s not news, but, since enabling comments and webmentions on my site, it’s become clear to me that – even on the indieweb – discussion doesn’t take place “below the line”, but on social media, whether that’s Twitter, Facebook or micro.blog
Previous note Pensions
Next note Getting your RSS feed right for social media syndication
Comments
Add a comment
Poorchop
I have come to find that you were 100% correct. Nobody out there is sending webmentions from their site to another. Website owners use webmentions to relay replies, likes, and reposts from social media sites. Nobody is going to leave a comment on a blog but if you syndicate a blog post to a site like Twitter, people are more likely to add their two cents exclusively through tweeting.
I guess the guys behind this technology have always acknowledged this truth.
Leon
@poorchop,
It’s pretty rare. Partly because setting this stuff up is still a pain: I’m still not sure whether I’m sending webmentions properly, although I know I can receive them.
Still, if you forget the technology, I think there’s some life in the asynchronous online conversation yet: I do get the odd BTL comment, and I occasionally stumble across a post with lots of responses. I even get the occasional email. If someone replies on their own site there’s a decent chance you’ll find out, however indirectly.
Twitter dying a death may well breath some life into the comment. I don’t think people will simply replace it with, say, Mastodon.
Webmentions
Comments and replies to this post from other sites and services, such as micro.blog and Mastodon.
Replies (1)
Poorchop
I went through a lot of effort to create a section of my site for sending mentions in order to say that 1.) I don’t see a comments section on your website and 2.) implementing a system just for sending mentions is incredibly cumbersome, which is why you might not see many. I have only done the bare minimum and I still have a long way to go.